HOFSTEDE DIMENSIONS IN CULTURES: A COMPARISON BETWEEN GREECE AND COLOMBIA
The Hofstede dimensions
are a very useful and interesting way to identify a specific set of behaviors
of a culture. Now, we thought in the scores of each point for Greek culture
and then, we compared our estimated scores with real scores and scores for
Colombia. These were the results:
Firstly, we determined
a 60% score in “PDI”, and this score is the real score. If we think on reasons
for this particular score, we can say that Greek people are more prone to
question higher ranking people, this especially due to the current economic situation
of country. It´s so similar to the situation in Colombia.
Respect to “IDV” we thought
that this score for Greek people was low (25%); real result is 35%. We think that main reason for this score is due
to Greek culture seems to be like Colombian culture in things like, for
example, familiar aspect. These characteristics prove a high level of collectivism.
Following the same
logic of the previous point, we considered that the aspect of masculinity (MAS)
was a quite high (near to 60%), and it was very similar to Colombian score, especially
considering the visions respect to gender roles in both cultures. The real score
is 57%.
Respect to uncertainly
avoidance (UAI), we also considered that this score was quite high (between 60%
and 70%). The real result is 100%, honestly this result surprised us, because we
didn’t expect it to be so high. Perhaps due to Greece recent history this
aspect has been reinforced in Greek culture. We can say that this aspect can be
high in more conservative cultures, Colombia and Greece are good examples; due
to this reason, perhaps their scores are so similar.
We already had defined
Greek culture as conservative or traditionalist, just like Colombian culture.
Due to this, we thought that their long-term orientation (LTO) could
have a quite low score (20%). Real score is 45%, it’s different but it isn´t a
high result.
Lastly, respect to the indulgence (IVR) we considered that this score could be high (70%); outside the stereotype of Greeks as people who like to celebrate, we thought that perhaps the Greeks are very optimistic and full of happiness, even with their problems. The real score (50%) isn’t as high as we thought. If we think on reasons to this score, we can think in Greek economic crisis as one of most important reasons why this score is not so high. Also, the result is different to Colombian score, perhaps because Colombians are much more optimistic about our problems.
You detailed the scores accurately. However, it would have been nice to read your interpretation of the meaning of the results! I would like to see more description on the next post! - Paul
ResponderEliminar